بررسی الگوی تحقق محله پایدار با رویکرد نوشهرگرایی مطالعه موردی: محله شهید هاشمی نژاد (پاچنار) مشهد

نوع مقاله : مقاله برگرفته از پایان نامه

نویسندگان

1 دانشجوی دکتری جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری پردیس بین الملل دانشگاه فردوسی مشهد

2 دانشیار گروه جغرافیا و برنامه‌ریزی شهری دانشگاه فردوسی مشهد

چکیده

چکیده
نوشهرگرایی در پاسخ به‌نتایج اجتماعی، زیست‌محیطی و پراکنش ناشی از توسعه‌های حومه‌ای در امریکا به وجود آمد و به یکی از رویکردهای جدید در شهرسازی قرن بیستم تبدیل گردیده و تمرکز آن توجه به انسان در برنامه‌ریزی شهری است. مفهوم تراکم بخشی از جنبش نوشهرگرایی در بخش محلی است بدین صورت که تراکم بهینه موثر بر تحقق مفهوم محله چگونه باید باشد، مورد توجه قرار می‌گیرد. روش تحقیق حاضر مبتنی بر روش توصیفی- تحلیلی با اهداف تحقیق تدوین و در
تحلیل‌های آماری از رگرسیون چند‌گانه جهت آزمون همبستگی میان متغیر‌ها و از فرایند تحلیل شبکه ANP جهت تحلیل داده‌ها و وزن دهی معیار‌ها و شاخص‌ها استفاده شده است. در این مقاله علاوه برتعیین شاخص‌های اثرگذار بر تراکم ساختمانی بر اساس نظریه نوشهرگرایی در سطح محله شهید هاشمی‌نژاد (پاچنار) واقع در حوزه مرکزی شهر مشهد به ارائه تراکم پیشنهادی با استفاده از نرم افزار GIS نیز پرداخته است. 6 معیار ( جمعیتی، دسترسی به خدمات، دسترسی پذیری، کالبدی‌فضایی، زیست‌محیطی و اقتصادی) و 24 زیر شاخص در سطح محله بررسی گردید که شاخص جمعیتی با ضریب وزنی 0.43 از 1 دارای بیشترین تاثیرگذاری را در نحوه توزیع تراکم ساختمانی در حوزه مورد مطالعه(محله شهید هاشمی‌نژاد) داشته‌اند. سپس با روی‌هم اندازی لایه شاخص‌ها در نرم افزار GIS تراکم پیشنهادی برای این محله را ارائه می‌گردد که نتایج حاصل نشان می‌دهد بیشترین تراکم پیشنهادی (زیاد و خیلی زیاد) در حاشیه خیابان‌های اصلی و مرز محله می‌باشد و هر چه به عمق بافت محله پیش می‌رویم از شدت تراکم کاسته می‌شود.
واژه‌های کلیدی: محلۀ پایدار، نوشهرگرایی، تراکم ساختمانی،ANP

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Investigating the Sustainable Neighborhood Indicators with a New Urbanism Approach Case Study: Shahid Hashemi Nejad Neighborhood (Pachenar) Mashhad *

نویسندگان [English]

  • azadeh tashakori 1
  • mohamad rahnama 2
  • mohamad shokiei 2
1 PhD student in Geography and Urban Planning at Ferdowsi University International Campus, Mashad, Iran.
2 Professor, Department of Geography and Urban Planning, Ferdowsi University International Campus, Mashhad, Iran
چکیده [English]

Introduction
Neighborhoods have historically been the residence place of different ethnic, racial, religious, and business owners in Iranian cities, which has played a significant role in the development of Iranian cities (Latifi and Chabok, 2011: 6).
Following the developments in contemporary urban contexts and replacing new urban contexts with old ones, the role and position of urban neighborhoods has weakened and instability has increased in the context of urban neighborhoods (Azizi, 2006: 36). Sustainable development seeks answers to problems as an approach in all dimensions. In the meantime, neo-urbanism, as a new approach to urban engineering, considers a complete spectrum of city planning and architecture response to unstable neighborhoods (Hajipour, Ketabchi, 2012: 83).
Consequences of neglecting the context of residential neighborhoods will increase instability in these contexts. In the meantime, density is one of the most important and fundamental issues in urban planning and tools for conducting and controlling urban development. Building density can be used as a tool to achieve the goals, principles, and criteria of desirable and sustainable urban development (Azizi, 2003: 6). Therefore, urban planners are trying to create the necessary conditions for sustainable development of the city by optimally determining and distributing the building density (Ramezani, 2009: 3).
The study area is Shahid Hashemi Nejad neighborhood of Mashhad whose density is not appropriate due to the worn-out body and the divergence of population resulting from the physical and social conditions of the neighborhood. Despite the increasing trend of building density in this area, the living population is on a downward trend, which is due to the diminishing role of housing and the increasing role of residential, commercial, and cultural activities. Therefore, there search objective, questions, and hypotheses are:
-          Determining the dimensions and indicators affecting the building density according to the neo-urbanism approach in Shahid Hashemi Nejad Neighborhood
-          Presentation of building density model according to neo-urbanism approach in Shahid Hashemi Nejad neighborhood
-          How is the sustainable neighborhoods model based on the principles of neo-urbanism in the study area?
-          It seems that Shahid Hashemi Nejad neighborhood does not have optimal and sustainable density in the current situation.
-          It seems that there is no positive relationship between density and stability in Shahid Hashemi Nejad neighborhood.
Materials and Methods:
The research method in this study is descriptive-analytical and correlational. Indicators are collected through exploratory theoretical foundations in both documentary and field formats and their relationships are analyzed and measured. The required information from the study area is obtained using a questionnaire. The face and content validity of the questionnaire were assessed and its reliability is evaluated by Cronbach's alpha coefficient. The sample size is calculated using Cochran formula as much as 343 people. The weights of the indicators were also obtained by the ANP method with questions from 15 academic experts.
Discussion and Results:
Factors affecting building density include physical-environmental, socio-cultural, and economic factors, which are the causes that building density determines in different parts of the city.
Weighing criteria and indicators using ANP method
In the present research, 6 clusters and 24 subgroups were analyzed in the overall design of the ANP image model. The weighting of criteria and indicators is based on the ANP model's weight spectrum.
The final indicators after localizing the indicators from documentary studies are as follows:
Table 1- Weighting the criteria and indicators





Dimensions


Criterion


Significance coefficient


Index


Significance coefficient




Sociocultural


Demographic factors


0.43


population density


0.82




Active population


0.18




Physical - environmental


Access to services


0.212


Access to training centers


0.36




Access to medical care


0.22




Access to health centers


0.18




Access to cultural centers


0.10




Access to religious centers


0.072




Access to sports centers


0.04




Accessibility


0.15


Local access network


0.47




International access network


0.29




Access to the bus station


0.16




Access to the subway station


0.09




Physical - environmental


Physical Space


0.06


Observance of privacy


0.43




Building Density


0.23




Number of floors


0.18




Type of Materials


0.09




Type of structure


0.06




environmental


0.04


Noise Pollution


0.37




environmental pollution


0.27




green space


0.17




Roadway traffic density


0.13




Pedestrian traffic density


0.05




Economic


0.11


Land prices


0.81




Employment rate


0.19





(Resource: Authors, 2019)
The process of combining criteria and indicators
The final and integrated zoning map pf the building density is achieved by overlapping all layers of criteria and indicators in the GIS environment.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Figure 1. Proposed building density map based on the overlapping of all layers (Drawing: Authors)
Conclusion and Recommendations:
-          The purpose of this research was to pursue the indicators affecting the building density based on the Neo-urbanism approach and criteria. Moreover, the variables affecting the building density in Shahid Hashemi Nejad Neighborhood (Pachenar) of Mashhad were also evaluated based on the influential approach to the mentioned index in the form of three general economic, socio-cultural, physical-environmental factors.
-          Concerning the effect of various factors on the distribution of building density, demographic index had the highest significance coefficient for the integration of indictors with a weight factor as much as 0.43 from 1, which had the most influence on the distribution of building density in the study area.
-          The result of the final integration of all layers indicate that the main street margins and neighborhood boundaries of the study are the best location for the highest building density (high and very high) and the inner parts of the neighborhood are suitable for the lowest building density.
Solutions:
-          Developing specific criteria to prevent increase or decrease in building density in different parts of the neighborhood
-          Restriction on sale of surplus building density for buildings that are in the low density range
-          Strengthening the service distribution system at the neighborhood level
-          Strengthening pedestrian network at the neighborhood level
-          Creating open and green spaces due to the lack of it at the neighborhood level and preventing damage caused by environmental pollution
-          Encourage the construction of complexes within the proposed high density building zones
-          Controlling high-rise construction at the neighborhood level
Keywords: Sustainable neighborhood, Neo-urbanism, Building density, ANP

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • new urbanism
  • sustainable neighborhoods
  • construction density
  • ANP
  • Shahid Hashemi Nejad neighborhood
  1. Boyko, Ch. and Cooper, R, (2011):Clarifying and re-conceptualising Density, Progress in Planning,76, pp. 1-61
  2. Garcia-Meion, M, javier ferris,O. Jeronimo Aznar, B, Pablo Aragones ,B ,and Rocio Poveda, B, (2008): Farmlandappraisal based on the ananlytic network Process, journal of Global Optimiziation, 42,pp.143-155.
  3. Foster, S., Hooper, P., Knuiman, M., Bull, F., Giles-Corti, B., )2016(: Are Liveable Neighbourhoods Safer eighbourhoods? Testing the Rhetoric on NewUrbanism and Safety from Crime in Perth, Western Australia’, Social Science & Medicine
  4. .Marans, R, (2015):Quality of urban life & environmental sustainability studies: Future linkage opportunities, Habitat International, 45, pp. 47-5
  5. Ramezani,Y,(2009): Determining Appropriate Method forDistribution of Building Density,Case study: Region 1 of Municipality of Mashhad. Thesis of Science in Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of art and Architecture, Shiraz University.
  6. Williams, M, ( 1985): Neighborhood Organizations: Seeds of a new Urban Life, We Sport, Greenwood Press, Westport Publication, america
  7. Saaty, T.L,(1999): "Fundamentals of the Analytic Network process" ,Processings of ISAHP1999 Japan.
  8. Power, A, (2004): Sustainable Communities and Sustainable Development: London. Sustainable Development commission.
  9. Steuteville, R, (2004): The New Urbanism: An alternative to modern, automobile-oriented planning development.
  10. References
    1. .Marans, R, (2015):Quality of urban life & environmental sustainability studies: Future linkage opportunities, Habitat International, 45, pp. 47-5
    2. Azizi, Mohammad Mehdi (2003): Density n Design: Principles and Criteria of urban density, Tehran University Press, Tehran First Edition.
    3. Azizi, Mohammad Mehdi (2006): "Sustainable Residential Neighborhood, Case study: (Narmak), Journal of Fine Arts, Eleventh Year, No. 27, Tehran, pp. 35-46.
    4. Boyko, Ch. and Cooper, R, (2011):Clarifying and re-conceptualising Density, Progress in Planning,76, pp. 1-61
    5. Chapmann, David (2005). Creating Neighborhoods and Places in the Human Environment, translated by Shahrzad Fariadi and Manouchehr Tabibian, University of Tehran Press, First Edition, Tehran.
    6. Foster, S., Hooper, P., Knuiman, M., Bull, F., Giles-Corti, B., )2016(: Are Liveable Neighbourhoods Safer eighbourhoods? Testing the Rhetoric on NewUrbanism and Safety from Crime in Perth, Western Australia’, Social Science & Medicine
    7. Garcia-Meion, M, javier ferris,O. Jeronimo Aznar, B, Pablo Aragones ,B ,and Rocio Poveda, B, (2008): Farmlandappraisal based on the ananlytic network Process, journal of Global Optimiziation, 42,pp.143-155.
    8. Hajipour, Khalil, Ketabchi, Emad, and Mohammad Hosseinpour (2012): "Modern Urbanization; a Way to Sustainable Neighborhoods", Manzar Magazine, Fourth Year, No. 18, Tehran, pp. 81-88.
    9. Mallak, Mohammad Mehdi (2014): «Assessing the Impacts of building density Selling on Social Concept of Neighborhood in Iranian Cities Case Study: Sarafrazan Neighborhood of Mashhad », Master of Urban and Regional Planning, Supervisor: Kiomars Irandoost, Faculty of Art and Architecture, University of Kurdistan.
    10. Mashhoudi, Sohrab (2010): Population and Building Density in Cities, Tehran, Mazinani Publications First Edition.
    11. Mofidi, Seyyed Majid and Leila Shayan (2007): "Sustainable Development and Planning of Iranian Desert Cities", Haftarshahr Journal, No. 21 and 22, Tehran, pp. 93-98.
    12. Mojtahedzadeh, Gholamhossein (1999): Urban Planning in Iran, First Edition, Payam Noor University Press, Tehran.
    13. Moshiri, Shahriar (2010): "Controlling and Conducting Urban Construction; Designing an Efficient System", Journal of City Identity, Vol. 4, No. 2, Tehran, pp. 23-30.
    14. Nazmfar, Hossein and Somayeh Roshan Roodi (2015): "Evaluation of Sustainability Level Development in District 9 of Mashhad Based on Hierarchical Models and Network Analysis", Quarterly Journal of Geography and Urban Planning, Vol. , No. 15, pp. 49-68.
    15. Power, A, (2004): Sustainable Communities and Sustainable Development: London. Sustainable Development commission.
    16. Rahimi, Hossein (2004): An Introduction to Geography and Sustainable Development of Iran, Oghlidos Publications, First Edition, Tehran.
    17. Ramezani,Y,(2009): Determining Appropriate Method forDistribution of Building Density,Case study: Region 1 of Municipality of Mashhad. Thesis of Science in Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of art and Architecture, Shiraz University.
    18. Rezaei Rad, Hadi (2011): Evaluation of High-Ranking Policies in a Detailed Plan with Emphasis on the Functional Spatial Organization of Tehran, Master's thesis in Urban and Regional Planning, Supervisor: Mojtaba Rafieian, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modarres University.
    19. Saaty, T.L,(1999): "Fundamentals of the Analytic Network process" ,Processings of ISAHP1999 Japan.
    20. Seqat Al-Islami, Amid al-Islam and Behnaz Aminzadeh (2013): "A Comparative Study of the Concept and Principles Used in the Iranian Neighborhood and the Western Neighborhood", Identity City, Seventh Year, No. 13, Tehran, pp. 33 - 45.

Steuteville, R, (2004): The New Urbanism: An alternative to modern, automobile-oriented planning development

  1. Williams, M, ( 1985): Neighborhood Organizations: Seeds of a new Urban Life, We Sport, Greenwood Press, Westport Publication, america